Angelina Jolie (left) and Melanie Griffith
06/20/2014 at 09:55 AM EDT
They call it "The First Commandment of Getting Inked"
: Never get your significant other's name tattooed anywhere on your body. You never know when things might end, and if they do, you might find yourself scarred for life – literally. (Or maybe not...
As with all commandments, there are some celebrities who just can't heed this rule. And they've paid the price.
After the inevitable breakup, many famous folks keep the tattoos as a reminder of their younger days. Other stars just can't bear to carry their former lover's name around with them wherever they go. Below, see the celebs who have removed, covered or otherwise altered the ink they got on behalf of their exes.
Johnny Depp in 1990 (left) and in 2008
Arguably the most famous celebrity tattoo do-over belongs to Johnny Depp
, who got the name of his girlfriend (and Edward Scissorhands
costar) Winona Ryder
emblazoned on his right shoulder as "Winona Forever." The inscription, sadly, was not prophetic. The couple broke up in the early '90s. In 1994, Depp had the last two letters of Ryder's first name removed, creating the motto "Wino Forever." As he told Playboy
, the new tattoo is "actually a bit more accurate."
Angelina Jolie in 2000 (left) and in 2014
has succeeded in scrubbing her public image of those wild days when she was married to Billy Bob Thornton, a feat which took some literal erasing. After her divorce from the Sling Blade
actor in 2003, Jolie removed the tattoo of his name from her left arm. She's since replaced it with the coordinates of her globe-spanning family's birthplaces – a handy metaphor for Jolie's image rehabilitation.
Melanie Griffith in 2012 (left) and 2014
had husband Antonio Banderas's name tattooed inside a heart in the 1990s, but after the couple split, Griffith apparently decided the sentiment no longer held. When the actress stepped out at the Italian Film Festival June 17, the heart remained, but Banderas's name had been conveniently – and messily – erased.
Eva Longoria in 2009 (left) and in 2014
star Eva Longoria
celebrated her marriage to basketball player Tony Parker with not one, not two, but three
tattoos marking the occasion. The first, a giant "NINE" on the back of her neck, was a reference to Parker's jersey number; the second, a small "07-07-07" on her wrist, was the day the couple were wed; the third, Parker's initials, is hidden somewhere on her body. After the couple divorced in 2010, Longoria waited two years, then got them all removed.
Heidi Klum in 2011 (left) and 2014
Seal famously called a kiss from a rose
"power, pleasure and pain" – which, we're guessing, is also the mixture of feelings his ex-wife Heidi Klum
felt when she got the tattoo of his name removed (well, mostly removed!) from her arm in 2013.
Marc Anthony's wrist in 2006 (inset) and in 2013
After his divorce from Jennifer Lopez
in 2011, Marc Anthony no longer wanted his tattoo to praise Lopez, so he buried it – under an elaborate cover-up.
Denise Richards's ankle in 2007 (left) and 2014
The union of Charlie Sheen
and Denise Richards
was not marked by an excess of forward planning. The couple pledged their devotion in 2002 by tattooing each other's names on their bodies ("I've never had anyone tattoo anything for me!" Richards told PEOPLE at the time
), but five years and one divorce later, both were regretting the ink. Sheen got the "Denise" on his wrist removed at the request of then-fiancée Brooke Mueller
; in revenge, Richards had the "Charlie" on her ankle turned into a beautiful fairy.
Kat Von D
When most stars get tattoos of their squeezes, they go for something small, like a first name or initials. Celebrity tattoo artist Kat Von D
chose a different approach. To honor her on-again, off-again relationship with fellow reality star Jesse James, Von D got a portrait of James as a young boy tattooed on her ribcage. Though she vowed to keep it after the couple broke up for the last time in 2011, the Miami Ink
star decided to get rid of the tattoo a year later. Probably because it was incredibly creepy.