Blogger Lisa Allison has been chronicling her search for Mr. Right on her website 100 First Dates. Having been on 99 dates in four years, she asked men to audition for date No. 100 – and she revealed her pick Friday on PEOPLE Now.
The winner? David, who offered Lisa a shot of whisky in his audition video. He beat out fellow finalists Ron and Ben after the three were chosen by fans who followed the project on social media and voted for their favorites.
The idea for the campaign started four years ago, when Allison, 36, a New York-based writer and comedian, was dumped by her longtime boyfriend.
"I learned so much and had so much fun," she says of the experiment. "I thank my ex every day for breaking up with me."
So, after 99 first dates, will No. 100 be the lucky last? Find out on Oct. 27, when Lisa and David return to PEOPLE Now to share how it went!