Criss, 28, is in talks to make a guest appearance in Hotel this fall, according to Entertainment Weekly.
The Glee star is said to be visiting the hotel as Justin, a hipster who attempts to escape the the craziness of Halloween night. However, Justin could be in for a few tricks rather than treats when Kathy Bates' character steps in.
Though fan favorite Jessica Lange won't be returning for AHS' fifth season, big names such as Lady Gaga, Angela Bassett and Max Greenfield will be joining the cast.
American Horror Story: Hotel premieres in October on FX.