Jaimie Alexander and Peter Facinelli End Their Engagement
02/19/2016 AT 07:20 PM EST
"Due to conflicting family and work commitments on opposite coasts, and after much consideration, Peter and Jaimie have chosen to part ways amicably and remain good friends," their reps tell PEOPLE exclusively.
The Supergirl actor, 42, and the Blindspot actress, 31, were first linked in November 2012 eight months after Facinelli split with wife Jennie Garth.
The duo last stepped out publicly at the 73rd Annual Golden Globe Awards in January.