'You're Not Marriage Material!': Football Star's Mom Is 'Gatekeeper' for Ladies Vying for His Heart in Match Made in Heaven
04/21/2016 AT 02:35 PM EDT
The former linebacker, 34, is the star of season 2 of the dating competition series, which pairs him with 18 bachelorettes, all hoping to become the next Mrs. Baggs – and PEOPLE has an exclusive look at the new season.
To add a twist to the dating show genre, the women live in a mansion with Baggs' mother, who isn't letting just anyone get close to her son.
"I don't feel like you're marriage material," she tells one woman, before adding to the camera: "I'm the gatekeeper, and if you want to take part in this, you've got to see me, bottom line."
The show is hosted and executive produced by Sherri Shepherd and also features Indianapolis Colts' spiritual advisor Ken Johnson, who will help make sure the ladies are on the show for the right reasons.
Match Made in Heaven season 2 premieres May 19 at 10 p.m. ET on WE tv.