Joe Don Rooney has a super-sleuth mom.
Gary LeVox once stole a truck.
One time, Jay DeMarcus was asked to leave his dentist's office for unruly behavior.
Keep scrolling for the reveal!
Joe Don Rooney – True! "I got busted smoking and I didn't even have a cigarette in my hand, nor was I smoking a cigarette at the time," he explains to PEOPLE Country. "My mom and I were sitting on the front porch having a conversation. She said, 'You been smoking, haven't you?' I was 16. I said, 'No!' She goes, 'You have nicotine fingers!' I look down and there's this little orange line between my middle finger and my index finger. I was like, 'You busted me mom! I'm sorry!'"
Gary Levox – True! "I stole my dad's truck and I couldn't get it in gear, so it was stuck at the end of the road. I couldn't even bring it back because I couldn't figure out how to get it in reverse. I was 14 or 15," LeVox recalls. "My brother had called my dad and told him what I had done. As I'm walking back to the house, he's pulling in and it wasn't good."
Jay DeMarcus – Lie! DeMarcus is actually a dentist's dream. "I've never in my life had a cavity," he says. "Not one!"