06/07/2014 at 10:00 AM EDT
Two things that don't go together: Amish mothers and New York City nightclubs. Well, they do now.
In an exclusive preview of Sunday's episode of Return to Amish
– a spinoff of Breaking Amish
, TLC's reality show about young Anabaptist adults torn between the pressures of their religion and their secular lives – the lines of faith and fun get blurred.
In the clip, ex-Amish model Kate Stoltzfus
talks her friend's very traditional mother into checking out New York's club scene. In her long dress and bonnet, modest, middle-aged Mary sticks out like a sore thumb – but soon proves she can party with the best of them.
After multiple drinks and even a flirtatious encounter, she ends up with a memorable new experience and a hangover she hopes to forget. Check out the clip.
Return to Amish
airs Sundays at 10 p.m. on TLC.