"It's hard your guy's situation," Osemwengie reveals. "Not only do you have what you guys went through with the infidelity, but now he wants kids."
"What?" asks a surprised Carney. "We went into our marriage knowing that was not anything [we wanted]."
When pressed by Osemwengie for her reasons for not wanting kids, Carney says, "I have like a hundred reasons why I don't want children. I just don't."
Prior to joining the show, the Carneys had discussed the subject, so Neal's confession his "new wife" Osemwengie is a game-changer. "I'm kind of taken aback when I hear that he's talking with her about that," admits Leah.
As for Osemwengie, she can't understand the couple's communication gap: "How did you miscommunicate having kids, it's either you do or you don't. I don't know what happened but their wires definitely got crossed."
RELATED VIDEO: Neal Admits He Cheated on His Wife on Seven Year Switch
Seven Year Switch airs Tuesdays (9 p.m. ET) on FYI.