See This/Skip That: An All But Flawless The Fault in Our Stars

06/06/2014 at 02:15 PM EDT

The Fault in Our Stars Review: An All But Flawless Adaptation
Ansel Elgort and Shailene Woodley in The Fault in Our Stars
James Bridges/20th Century FOX/AP
Based on John Green's ginormously popular YA novel, this is a sweet, simple, dignified movie about young lovers whose every move is chaperoned by death.

It seems safe to say that it will have millions of people verklempt between now and forever.

When they meet in a cancer support group, Hazel Grace Lancaster (Shailene Woodley) and  Augustus Waters (Ansel Elgort) share a sense of gallows humor, but she considers her  foreshortened life with pointed intensity, and he stays afloat (sometimes desperately)  with gallant charm. Where they connect – and the pair do connect, wholly – is on a  level of existential and romantic bliss.

The amazing thing is that the audience is transported there, too, for a time. And then ...

It would be unfair to reveal more of the story than that, even if the book's huge  readership knows the outcome and will probably be wet-eyed even while ordering  tickets on Fandango.

At any rate, fans will find little to complain about in this adaptation. (If they do, they're silly.) Hazel's voiceover narration in the movie doesn't capture wholly the extremely precise  tone of the book's Hazel: A sort of calculated lack of affect combined with deadpan humor, somewhere between Holden Caulfield and Hemingway, and absolutely right for a teenager who has spent years living with her cancer. The early Scarlett Johannson, the one in Ghost World, would have been perfect.

But the 22-year-old Woodley is flawless: natural, grounded, smart, with alert eyes, just enough edge and a readiness to yield to happiness when it arrives in the form of Ansel Elgort (who's 20). She is terrific.

Elgort's performance is launched as a major charm offensive and, if it had been  sustained at that level, would have been exhausting. But his boyish handsomeness  doesn't keep him from being awkward and vulnerable – from some angles, he suggests a more strapping Michael Cera – and the dominant element becomes a powerful tenderness.

Together, he and Woodley make one of the most believable couples to turn up on a  movie screen in years. 

In a scene that could have played very badly, they share their first kiss in Anne Frank's house in Amsterdam – and the tourists surrounding them, rather than thinking this is what you should expect of a nation that previously sent over  Justin Bieber, burst into applause and shouts of "bravo."

You agree with them: We've reached this moment watching Hazel lug her oxygen tank up  flight after flight of narrow stairs as Augustus worries for her – and all the while we're aware of Frank's words about life and death and hope. It's a validation, not a blasphemy. It's Woodley and Ansort who make it so.

I do have several problems with the movie, but as soon as I propose them I will for the most part withdraw them.



1. The movie has been shot, on a modest reported budget of $12 million, with very little concrete detail of time and place – it doesn't look much better than something you might watch on the CW.

But: This serves to keep the camera focused on Woodley and Elgort, and prevents their chemistry from being diluted.

2. Peter Van Houten (played by Willem Dafoe). The lovers visit Amsterdam on a pilgrimage to meet Peter Van Houten, the reclusive author of a book called An Imperial Affliction (the title is from an Emily Dickinson poem, "There's a Certain Slant of Light"). Hazel is obsessed with this mysterious novel, which ends midsentence and has something to do with a dying girl and a hamster named Sisyphus. The book sounds ridiculous, even though it clearly isn't meant to, and Van Houten turns out to be a mean, bitter drunk who practically throws the couple into the city's canals. He and his novel never completely escape the feeling of having been planted in the narrative. Even the fine Dafoe, looking like playwright David Mamet in a peculiarly foul mood and spitting out his words as if he were grinding up shards of glass, can't make him quite real.

But: Without Van Houten, we would not have that kiss in Anne Frank's house. It may just be that he's in that club of characters – Miss Havisham in Great Expectations, Boo Radley in To Kill a Mockingbird, even the Wizard of Oz – who confront young people with the  terrifying presence of blighted adulthood. And yet they allow those stories' heroes to move on, almost magically, to a new wonderment.

And that's what happens to Hazel and Augustus. No wonder everyone falls in love with them as they fall in love.

See This/Skip That: An All But Flawless The Fault in Our Stars| The Fault in Our Stars, Movie News, Ansel Elgort, Shailene Woodley, Willem Dafoe, DVDs, Home Video Products, Media Products

Ali MacGraw in Love Story (left), Ansel Elgort and Shailene Woodley in The Fault in Our Stars and Julia Roberts in Steel Magnolias

Everett

Follow PEOPLE on Facebook!




Sam Trammell Talks The Fault in Our Stars and His Sons

Your Reaction

Follow Us

On Newsstands Now

Bindi Irwin: Remembering My Dad
  • Bindi Irwin: Remembering My Dad
  • Adam Levine's Wedding Details!
  • James Garner: 1928-2014

Pick up your copy on newsstands

Click here for instant access to the Digital Magazine

blog comments powered by Disqus
Advertisement

From Our Partners

Watch It

Editors' Picks

Latest Photos

Photo Special

Who's Due Next?

From Our Partners