Well, if you're Toby Keith, you go out for Mexican and sing a little karaoke.
After Keith, 54, performed a montage of Haggard's biggest hits along with Haggard's backing band the Strangers and Haggard's youngest son Ben at the ACCAs on Sunday night, he and and the 23-year-old Haggard headed out for some dinner – and proceeded to make the night of their fellow restaurant patrons.
Don't miss a beat of country music news, photos and videos! Click here to get all this and more in the PEOPLE Country Newsletter.
"Went for Mexican food with Toby and he took over the karaoke....." Ben Haggard shared on Instagram along with a video of Keith's impromptu performance of Kenny Rogers' 1980 hit "Lady." "Seriously a night to remember."
And if you have serious FOMO about not being there, you're not alone. Even Keith's daughter, singer Krystal Keith, replied to the video with, "Killed it! Wish I could've been there."