Fear Turns 20: Celebrate with the Worst Boyfriends of Film

04/12/2016 AT 10:00 AM EDT

Long before the McConaissance, a different actor brought chest-thumping to the forefront of pop culture, though in a considerably different context.

That man was Mark Wahlberg, and he was portraying roller coaster enthusiast and dad's-worst-nightmare-of-a-boyfriend David McCall in the brutally bonkers relationship thriller Fear.

For two decades, Fear has educated slumber parties on the dangers of dating a man you sense might have an unchecked personality disorder and the ability to decapitate a dog. Just say "no," ladies – even if the guy has biceps like Wahlberg.

While it seems like Reese Witherspoon had to suffer through the worst boyfriend in film history, somehow there are dudes who make Mr. McCall's vengeful, 90-minute rampage look bearable.

Let's meet those winners now:

Andy of Wet Hot American Summer


One of the best lines in this ensemble comedy of future stars shows exactly why Paul Rudd's counselor character makes a horrible boyfriend. Moody, stupid and allergic to responsibility, Andy is going to shrug off anything that causes ripples in his lazy pool of cool – like beautiful women looking for love.

Cal Hockney of Titanic


We all saw you get on that boat meant for women and children, Billy Zane! No wonder Rose chose potentially freezing to death on a door (that was certainly big enough for two) instead of you.

J.D. of Heathers


Much like Marky Mark in Fear, Christian Slater's trench coat devotee J.D. has that dangerous allure that draws in innocent teens dabbling in darkness. It's when that rebellious nature turns into a killing spree that you know it's definitely time to get out.

Patrick Bateman of American Psycho


Speaking of homicide! Christian Bale's yuppie archetype really hits the bad boyfriend trifecta: He cheats, he kills and he takes longer to get ready than you do. Reese Witherspoon really knows how to pick 'em.

Billy Loomis of Scream


Not only does Skeet Ulrich's floppy-haired boyfriend character murder almost all of Neve Campbell's favorite people, he still finds time to take her virginity. Imagine the therapy she's in for! (If you haven't seen Scream yet, that's your fault. The movie came out almost 20 years ago. It's too late to cry foul on spoilers.)

David Goldman of An Education


It's the classic skeevy old dude long con. Peter Sarsgaard sweeps a teenage girl (Carey Mulligan) off her feet with his worldliness and maturity, only to reveal later that he is actually married with a family. Oops, yo.

Chris Wilton of Match Point


Jonathan Rhys Meyers seduces engaged woman (Scarlett Johansson), ends her relationship while staying in his own, gets her pregnant, demands she gets rid of the baby and then kills her. In other words, it's only slightly worse than using Tinder.

Trip of The Virgin Suicides


Any guy – even Josh Harnett – who takes your virginity and then leaves you in the middle of a field is not a good guy.

Jim of Edward Scissorhands


Unable to deal with that fact that his girlfriend (Winona Ryder) enjoys spending time with a kind scissors-handed man, an all-grown-up Anthony Michael Hall does everything he can to ruin the the new guy's life, including framing him for assault and burglary. Jealously suits no man.

Willy Jack Pickens of Where the Heart Is


Abandoning a pregnant Natalie Portman in a Walmart to have her baby is a surefire way to earn a spot in the bad boyfriend Hall of Fame.
blog comments powered by Disqus

From Our Partners