Following about a year of dating – and a brief split during which Levine dates model Nina Agdal – the Maroon 5 frontman reunites with Behati Prinsloo, and pops the question. "He called my dad, he was a stand-up guy, called my mom, he did the whole thing," the model tells Extra, adding to ET Canada, "I am so happy and excited and still can't believe it's true!"
"As a musician, you have fantasies that you want to win Grammys, but I didn't really think that this was on the table," Levine says of being named PEOPLE's Sexiest Man Alive. "I was just amazed and stunned and it almost seemed like they were kidding, but they weren't, so that's cool."
Congratulations are in order as Levine and Prinsloo tie the knot on July 19, 2014, in front of 275 guests at Flora Farms in Los Cabos, Mexico. "I definitely feel like I'm sitting in the chair I'm supposed to be sitting in right now," Levine tells PEOPLE shortly before the nuptials. "It all feels very natural."
BIOGRAPHY (top to bottom): Splash News Online; Mike Pont/FilmMagic