Matthew McConaughey & Josh Lucas
As if the bedroom-blue eyes weren't enough. These two southern-born actors can both do the "howdy-ma'am" drawl and dress up their dimples with the same five o'clock shadow.

Leonardo DiCaprio & Eric Dane
The Departed star and Grey's McSteamy share hairlines and bone structure.

Michael Vartan & Patrick Wilson
Chiseled chins and prominent foreheads lend an aura of intelligence to the dashing Alias agent and the indie actor.

Will Ferrell & Dane Cook
Stranger than fiction? There's something uncanny in how these comics' facial traits mimic each other.

Jason Lee & Ronnie Vannucci
Must be karma. The mustachioed My Name Is Earl actor meets his doppelgänger in the drummer for the Killers.

Michael Ealy & D.L. Hughley
Sparkling eyes plus kissable lips add up to irresistible for the Sleeper Cell and Studio 60 stars.

Matt Leinart & Brody Jenner
Manly stubble and bold eyebrows unite these brown-eyed boys—a quarterback and the son of an Olympian.

Zach Braff & Raffaello Follieri
A Scrubs doc's been cloned! Behold the tousled bangs and lush lips of Anne Hathaway's businessman beau.

Check out more sexy lookalikes at People.com
A bonus round of hot double takes is now online. Log on for the extended photo gallery and more surprise matchups.

This week's cover

On Newsstands Now!

Saved by the Bell Reunion

The hookups, the meltdowns, the memoires

The case reveals what was really going on what they think of each other now!

Get 4 FREE PREVIEW Issues! Click here now