Bill Rancic Defends His Wife Giuliana After Fashion Police Controversy: 'I Tried to Get Them to Release the Footage' 42 years, 2,191 covers and 55,436 stories from PEOPLE magazine's history for you to enjoy
- Is the New 365 by Whole Foods Actually Cheaper? One PEOPLE Reporter Investigates
- Read the Cover Story: Steve Harvey: From Homeless to Having It All
- School District's Proposed Ban On Skinny Jeans as Anti-Bullying Tactic Met with Swift Backlash
- Gwyneth Paltrow and Chris Martin Reach Divorce Settlement
- Kris Jenner Shares Touching Birthday Message with Scott Disick: 'I Am So Blessed to Be Able to Call You My Son
On Newsstands Now
- Matthew McConaughey: In His Own Words
- Jessa Duggar's Wedding Album
- Brittany Maynard's Final Days
Pick up your copy on newsstands
Click here for instant access to the Digital Magazine
People Top 5
LAST UPDATE: Tuesday February 10, 2015 01:10PM EST
PEOPLE Top 5 are the most-viewed stories on the site over the past three days, updated every 60 minutes
- May 02, 1983
- Vol. 19
- No. 17
Linda Wolf's Tell-a-Maid Phrasebook May Be a Hit with Householders, but It's a Slap in the Face to Some Hispanics
Wolf, whose two-bedroom Valley condo is serviced twice a month by a Mexican woman, says horrendous mistakes based on misunderstanding abound, hence the popularity of her product. There was the maid who threw a $400 cashmere sweater in the washer and dryer, another who used toilet bowl cleaner to scrub hardwood floors. But what Wolf calls an innocent attempt to bridge the language gap has caused a furor among some Hispanic leaders in Los Angeles, who denounce Tell-a-Maid (and its companion, Tell-a-Gardener) as insulting, demeaning and racist. Among their complaints is the commanding tone of the memos, which contain instructions like "Lave los platos" (Wash the dishes) and "Por favor...iesto no lo toque!"(Please...don't touch this!) Tell-a-Gardener contains memos with Spanish requests, such as "Trim around the sprinklers" and "Wash down the patio." Critics say the memos are dehumanizing. "I know it is a means of communication, but it eliminates that human contact and creates little robots," says State Assemblywoman Gloria Molina, whose L.A. district is heavily Hispanic. The memos, she complains, are "just like snapping at somebody." Counters Wolf: "I wanted to put 'please' before every single instruction, but I didn't have the room. I do write 'por favor' (please) on most pages."
Such little pleasantries hardly appease the opposition. Sophia Esparza of the Chicana Service Action Center, an organization aiding Hispanic women, things Tell-a-Maid is "a slap in the face" to domestics. "It's ironic that in many of the homes where Tell-a-Maid is used, Poochie gets much better treatment than some of the maids and gardeners," she says. Esparza and other foes of the books suggest that employers learn Spanish. "Anybody with half a brain would be able to learn repetitive statements," Esparza says. "I don't think for the amount of money they [employers] pay people, that they should require Rhodes scholars."
Criticism of Wolf's work is mild compared to the anger generated by a similar Spanish-English directive being used by farm owners in California. In much sterner language it tells Mexican farm hands, "You live like a pig."
Wolf, who consulted with several domestics while writing the instructions, is surprised by the reaction to her memos and downplays charges that they stereotype all Hispanics as maids or gardeners. "It is not a secret that the majority of working maids and gardeners in this area are Spanish-speaking," she says. An estimated 60 percent of domestics in Southern California are Hispanic, including some who entered the U.S. illegally, occasionally with the help of the wealthy, who then employ them in their homes. As for the memos, Wolf insists that they are a common business practice: "I'm not offended if someone leaves me a note."
Wolf came up with the idea for Tell-a-Maid after a friend asked to borrow notes like "Please clean the refrigerator," which Wolf left for her own domestic. Though laughed off by distributors when she first had the memos printed, Wolf eventually cajoled some 100 businesses—from car washes to pharmacies in swank neighborhoods—to display Tell-a-Maid.
Not all the reaction has been negative, even among domestics. "It's very important to me," says Alicia Orrego, 30, a Colombian domestic. "Sometimes it's necessary to use because I forget the words." Observes another immigrant: "Latins should not complain about it; it's more employment." But one store employee insists that customers don't take the book seriously. "Most people buy it as a joke," says Nancy Bradley, a Doubleday bookstore clerk. "I've never seen anyone admit they were buying it for themselves. Always for a friend."
Wolf is undeterred by critics and hopes to market Tell-a-Maid in other cities with large Hispanic populations. She is finishing a Tell-a-Maid guide for domestics who take care of children and plans another for doctors and their patients. Wolf insists that the general public is behind her. "They know my basic intention is to help people."
Treat Yourself! 4 Preview Issues
The most buzzed about stars this minute!