DAVID CHOLEWA MAY HAVE THOUGHT he was doing the Lord's work when he and four of his brothers began selling a line of nun dolls in 1995, but Sister Beth Rindler saw things differently. The brothers, concluded Rindler, cochair of the National Coalition of American Nuns, were simply cashing in on the sisters. "Here are these people outside of us," says Rindler, "using our image to make money."

Last month the 2,000-member coalition, an activist group representing roughly 2 percent of the U.S. sisterhood, urged a boycott of Cholewa's St. Joseph, Mich., company, Blessings, Expressions of Faith, which sells 20-inch dolls dressed in the garb of 32 Roman Catholic orders for $139 to $199 each. Rindler, 64, has never shied away from a fight. Over the past decade she has expressed opposition to the Pope over his stands against same-sex marriage and the ordination of women, and has written President Clinton to protest human rights violations in Guatemala.

Still, Cholewa, who was reared with six brothers and two sisters in a blue-collar Polish-Catholic family in Lombard, Ill., is bewildered by her criticism. "We're promoting a symbol of the Church," he says. "What these habits represent, you cannot knock." He and his brothers quizzed nuns on such details as the number of pleats in their habits. "I can't think of a time they didn't cooperate," he says. "Some even sent swatches of fabric."

Cholewa's salary of $20,000 a year helps support his wife, a waitress, and their two young daughters in a modest townhouse in Geneva, Ill. Fortunately for him, the boycott threat has stirred curiosity about his mininuns: Catalog requests have suddenly increased. "This whole thing," says Cholewa, "could be a blessing in disguise."

This week's cover

On Newsstands Now!

Saved by the Bell Reunion

The hookups, the meltdowns, the memoires

The case reveals what was really going on what they think of each other now!

Get 4 FREE PREVIEW Issues! Click here now