If you ever meet Winter Olympics organizer Mitt Romney, feel free to praise him for helping to rescue this year's Games from a bribery scandal and a deficit of nearly $400 million. Just don't tell him he's arrestingly handsome. "Nothing embarrasses Mitt more than when someone says he's good-looking," says Cindy Gillespie, a colleague on the Salt Lake Organizing Committee. Yet now that Romney, 55, who lives in Belmont, Mass., is the GOP candidate for governor of his home state, it's hard not to notice his blinding smile. Says Olympic skeleton gold medalist Jimmy Shea, 33: "I'd be really excited to look like him when I get to be his age." Political critics like to paint the 6'2" Mormon as a too-perfect Ken doll. The son of former Michigan governor George Romney amassed a multimillion-dollar fortune as a venture capitalist at Boston's Bain Capital and has been married 33 years to his high school sweetheart, Ann, with whom he has five sons. But childhood pal Tom McCaffrey insists that while Romney's "family looks like a Gap ad, which makes us all a bit cynical," he is a man of "immense credibility and character—which shows in his face."