From PEOPLE Magazine Click to enlarge
Singer-songwriter Lisa Loeb is usually right at home in front of a crowd. But walking down the staircase turned aisle in front of 275 wedding guests in a light pink Amsale gown and 3 1/2" Charles David heels, "I was thinking, 'Maybe I should've rehearsed this,'" she recalls. "It was one time where I was winging it, but I wanted to be in the moment."

The moment was right in tune. During the Jewish ceremony at the Manhattan restaurant Brasserie 8 1/2 on Jan. 31, Loeb, 40, and Late Night with Conan O'Brien music supervisor Roey Hershkovitz, 30, "took turns laughing and crying," says the groom. The pair, who met at a business meeting in 2006, planned their wedding in two months. "We wanted both classy and fun touches," says Loeb. So with the help of planner Amy Shey Jacobs, she dreamed up an all-white winter wonderland reception—complete with deer figurines and "custom-made Muppets that looked like us that guests danced with."

And danced they did. After a buffet dinner, a jazz swing band and a deejay played tunes until midnight. Then it was time for the afterparty at a local bar, where the newlyweds and their guests played the video game Rock Band until 4 a.m. "At the end we were exhausted," says Loeb, "but it was the most fun night ever!"