Archive Page - 08/16/13 41 years, 2,180 covers and 55,277 stories from PEOPLE magazine's history for you to enjoy
- Outlander Recap: Claire Is Forced to Choose Between Jamie and Frank
- Read the Cover Story: Jill and Derick Dillard Share Their Baby Boy's Dramatic Arrival
- Hillary Scott on Lady Antebellum's Tour Bus Fire: It's 'Nothing Compared to What It Could Have Been'
- The Untold Story of Rock Hudson's Final Days
- Jill (Duggar) and Derick Dillard: Israel David's Birth Brought Us Closer Together
On Newsstands Now
- Matthew McConaughey: In His Own Words
- Jessa Duggar's Wedding Album
- Brittany Maynard's Final Days
Pick up your copy on newsstands
Click here for instant access to the Digital Magazine
People Top 5
LAST UPDATE: Tuesday February 10, 2015 01:10PM EST
PEOPLE Top 5 are the most-viewed stories on the site over the past three days, updated every 60 minutes
- July 04, 2011
- Vol. 76
- No. 26
Could Casey Go Free?
Prosecutors Presented a Mountain of Evidence Against the Accused Florida Mom. But as the Defense Unrolls Its Case, Key Questions Linger-and Legal Experts Say the Jury Could Acquit If They Don't Get Answers
It's a desire shared by the millions of trial watchers who have become hooked on the twisty case, along with the spectators who line up daily for a chance to see the drama and its key players up close. Message boards are flooded with angry posts calling for Casey's conviction. Meanwhile the 25-year-old defendant has displayed everything from scowls to sobs to stone-faced indifference as she sits beneath the words emblazoned high in the courtroom: Equal Justice Under The Law. Yet despite riveting testimony from more than 30 witnesses and 315 pieces submitted into evidence, the mystery surrounding Caylee Marie Anthony's disappearance on June 16, 2008, largely remains as vexing as ever. Among the unanswered questions when prosecutors rested their case in a tension-filled Orlando courtroom on June 15: When exactly did Caylee die? Where did she die? If, as the state claims, she was murdered by her mother-why? And perhaps the most surprising question of all: Could Casey Anthony possibly the most hated woman in America right now-possibly go free?
Quite simply: yes. "This is definitely not a slam-dunk case," says Karin Moore, a former criminal-defense attorney and law professor at Florida A&M University. "The state doesn't have an eyewitness. They don't have a confession, so most of the evidence is circumstantial." An acquittal-or a conviction on a lesser charge-is hardly far-fetched. "There are gaps in the prosecution's theories, and the jury will notice them," says New York City defense attorney Stuart Slotnick. A prosecution source counters that the evidence against Casey is substantial and sufficient. "People hear 'circumstantial' and think that means it's a weak case," the source says of the evidence, which ranges from the location of Caylee's remains to duct tape placed over her nose and mouth (see page 53). "But what it means is that we built a case using a lot of evidence. There is no one smoking gun."
The jury may not see it that way. Sequestered and cut off from friends, family and all media coverage of the case, "there's an enormous amount of pressure on them," says Dr. Philip K. Anthony, a top trial consultant. Seated some 15 feet directly across the artificially lit courtroom from the defendant six days a week, "they're quizzical about Casey herself," he says. "She's fairly poised when she needs to be and emotional when she needs to be. They're probably very interested in that." Confined to a solitary cell in prison (see box), she commands the spotlight in court: On June 14, she riveted onlookers when she pointedly looked away after her mother mouthed "I love you" upon leaving the stand. "She does love Casey," the Anthony family friend says of Cindy. "Casey is her daughter. Both George and Cindy love her unconditionally."
Yet they both listened as defense attorney Jose Baez stunned the courtroom in his opening arguments with claims-yet to be solidified-that Caylee accidentally drowned in the family swimming pool and that Casey's father, George, had helped cover up the death after years of sexually abusing Casey. (George has denied both claims.) Now that the defense is under way, the jury will be paying close attention to whether those bombshells are backed up with hard evidence. "Baez made a promise: 'You're going to hear that Casey was sexually abused,'" says assistant state attorney Stacey Honowitz. "Now the defense is in a situation where they have to prove something."
Of course, the burden of proof rests with the prosecution, not the defense. And the multitude of photos showing a fun-loving Casey partying in the weeks following Caylee's disappearance may not be enough to establish a motive for the murder-or that Casey had planned it in advance. "Party pictures can prove that she was out partying later but not that she intentionally killed [her daughter]," says Karin Moore. Nor is the wealth of testimony exposing Casey's astonishing web of lies-including the 30 days she kept Caylee's disappearance a secret-surefire proof that she killed her daughter. "Being a liar does not mean she's a murderer," says Slotnick. "It means she's an unlikable liar." Still, should Casey be called to testify by the defense-something experts say is necessary to beef up her claim of sexual abuse-"her credibility has already been attacked," says Moore. "If she decides to testify, that will hurt her."
Regardless of whether Casey testifies, the prosecution source says the state is confident she will not walk away a free woman. "The evidence is there," says the source. "Her actions are there. Her own words are there. I don't like to look at it like 'win' or 'lose,' because, as the judge says, this is not just a game. I believe we have a solid case."
Ultimately, of course, the decision rests with the five men and seven women seated attentively-and most often impassively-in the jury box who must agree unanimously on a verdict. "No one knows what the jurors are going to do, in part because the jurors themselves don't know," says Dr. Philip K. Anthony. "They are looking over at Casey and trying to figure out: 'Who is she?'" As with the other perplexing questions surrounding Casey Anthony, the answer remains, for now, stubbornly out of reach.
April 18, 2015
Treat Yourself! 4 Preview Issues
The most buzzed about stars this minute!