From PEOPLE Magazine Click to enlarge
KATHIE LEE GIFFORD & HODA KOTB as Lucy and Ethel

"The I Love Lucy costume was definitely my favorite," says Gifford of her 2010 look. "It was much more comfortable than the others."

ANN CURRY as Cher

"It was Cher's real costume!" says Curry of her 2006 outfit. "I was beyond intimidated. I felt naked in front of millions of people!"

NATALIE MORALES as Eddie Munster

Morales's 2007 get-up "was spot-on," she says. "The SNL team always helps us with our wigs, wardrobe and pointy ears!"

AL ROKER & MATT LAUER as Puff Daddy and J.Lo

In 2000 Lauer stunned viewers in J.Lo's infamous Grammy dress. "I was blown away by how easily I adapted to high heels," he jokes.

KOTB & GIFFORD as Yoda and C-3PO

"I remember thinking, 'Am I Yoda because my name's Hoda?'"says Kotb, who added lipstick to her 2009 look "to make me feel better."