Star Tracks: Monday, May 16, 2016 42 years, 2,191 covers and 55,436 stories from PEOPLE magazine's history for you to enjoy
- Beloved 13-Year-Old Gymnast Allegedly Killed By Older Brother 'Was Always So Happy,' Says Former Coach
- Read the Cover Story: JFK Jr.: The John We Loved
- WATCH: Can You Guess Who Made Scott Wolf Starstruck?
- One Year Later: Remembering Bobbi Kristina Brown's Life in Photos
- Stop Everything: There's Officially a New Peanut M&M's Flavor
On Newsstands Now
- Matthew McConaughey: In His Own Words
- Jessa Duggar's Wedding Album
- Brittany Maynard's Final Days
Pick up your copy on newsstands
Click here for instant access to the Digital Magazine
People Top 5
LAST UPDATE: Tuesday February 10, 2015 01:10PM EST
PEOPLE Top 5 are the most-viewed stories on the site over the past three days, updated every 60 minutes
- January 14, 2013
- Vol. 79
- No. 1
Bethenny's Split: What Went Wrong
After Less Than Three Years of Marriage, Bethenny Frankel and Jason Hoppy Call It Quits. Inside Their Emotional Breakup
But by last month, what seemed to be mere bumps in their relationship had turned into mountains. On Dec. 23 Frankel, 42, announced that she and Hoppy, 41, were separating after nearly three years of marriage. "This is an immensely painful and heartbreaking time for us," the reality star said in a statement, which came after weeks of renewed speculation over their union. "This was an extremely difficult decision that as a woman and a mother I have to accept as the best choice for our family." While a source says a reconciliation is out of the question, both Frankel and Hoppy plan to keep things amicable for their daughter Bryn, 2. In the meantime "Bethenny is devastated," says a friend. As for Hoppy, who is still wearing his wedding ring, "the split has been tough. You go into a marriage thinking it's going to be forever. When you realize it's not, it's really hard-especially when a child is involved."
For the pair, whose whirlwind courtship, surprise pregnancy and shotgun wedding were documented on-camera for Bravo's The Real Housewives of New York City, Bethenny Getting Married? and Bethenny Ever After, it's a sad end to what had appeared to be a storybook romance. "There was no one turning point that caused this," says the friend. Though the couple had argued over the years, "they tried to make it work, but it just got too hard to be husband and wife."
Yet for a few years, it had seemed that the reality star-whose hardscrabble upbringing, acerbic one-liners and romantic woes made her a fan favorite on Housewives-had gotten her happy ending. Long estranged from her mother and late father, Frankel-who had been married once and had two broken engagements-met Hoppy in 2008. The pair wed in 2010 before welcoming their daughter Bryn that same year. As Frankel worked hard developing her now-successful Skinnygirl brand, she attributed her success to Hoppy's support. "He's my anchor," she told PEOPLE in 2010. "He taught me that being taken care of was emotional and not financial."
While friends say the reality-TV cameras didn't play a role in their split, Frankel herself admitted that her increasingly intense lifestyle placed a strain on her marriage. In 2011 she sold her Skinnygirl cocktail empire for a reported $120 million while continuing to oversee new lines of shapewear and beauty products and a series of books and DVDs (she also helped her website's former food blogger lose 66 lbs., see page 102). Last summer she launched her own daytime talk show which, after a successful six-week trial run in six cities, will be nationally syndicated this fall. "The stress of my business may exacerbate our issues," she told PEOPLE last May. Her level of dedication to her work may have also led to problems. "With Bethenny it was her way or the highway," says a source. "If you are a person who surrounds yourself with people telling you, 'You are right; we will bend over backwards to make things happen for you,' you will have a tough time in marriage. Marriage doesn't work that way."
All the while, Hoppy continued his own business ventures, helping out on an unofficial basis with Skinnygirl, despite Frankel's offer of a full-time gig. ("I want to work with you, not for you," Hoppy told his wife on Ever After.) "He did well but wasn't a high roller by any means. Bethenny thought she'd be the breadwinner and he'd be a stay-at-home dad," says a longtime friend of the couple's. "That didn't fly."
As the pair began arguing more and more, they were dealt a devastating blow last winter, when Frankel suffered a miscarriage during her second pregnancy. "I hit rock bottom when I heard it would have been a girl," she told PEOPLE in July. "Bryn would have had a sister. I felt like this was meant to be, like it was my last chance to have another baby."
Still reeling from the loss, Frankel pulled herself together to launch her talk show. When the family relocated to L.A. briefly last summer for taping, "it was stressful for him because he's a fish out of water," Frankel said of her East Coast born-and-raised husband. The idea of relocating to L.A. when the show returned in 2013 was an ongoing source of conflict. "It would have been devastating to his family," says the mutual friend. "And Jason didn't want his daughter raised in L.A." So once the show's six-week run wrapped, "she took six months off to be with her family, be a mom and a wife and quietly live their life."
Sadly, that attempt at healing their marriage didn't work. Now Frankel and Hoppy are figuring out how to move on. They still live together in their Tribeca loft, a friend tells PEOPLE. And a source says that Frankel successfully "fought tooth and nail" to move Bethenny's production to New York City next fall. (A rep for Telepictures Productions, which produces Bethenny, says the show will "likely" move to New York.) "Bethenny would have loved to do the show in L.A., but she will not do that to her family," says a source. "No matter what, she wants to keep her family together."
- With Elizabeth McNeil/New York City,
- K.C. Baker/New York City,
- Sara Hammel/New York City.
Treat Yourself! 4 Preview Issues
The most buzzed about stars this minute!