From PEOPLE Magazine Click to enlarge
75% OF PEOPLE.COM READERS Loved it

AMANDA SEYFRIED in Alexander McQueen

Seyfried loved her custom organza gown so much, she "had no backup dress," says her stylist Elizabeth Stewart.

58% OF PEOPLE.COM READERS Hated it

SALMA HAYEK PINAULT in Alexander McQueen

"The look was sexy-smoldering but chic," says her makeup artist Jo Strettell for St. Tropez.

56% OF PEOPLE.COM READERS Hated it

ANNE HATHAWAY in Prada

The Oscar winner was going for "classic elegance" in this column gown, says her makeup artist Kate Lee. "She felt great!"

65% OF PEOPLE.COM READERS Loved it

ZOE SALDANA in Alexis Mabille Couture

Saldana's corseted gown "had a French feel," says her stylist Petra Flannery. "The shape was gorgeous."