From PEOPLE Magazine Click to enlarge
ELITE SWEET red velvet cake, $39.95; harryanddavid.com

HOT SEASONING Butcher Salt, $24.95 for 17.6 oz.; crateandbarrel.com

BELOVED BALSAMIC Fattoria Estense 12-year aged balsamic vinegar, $29.95 for 8.5 oz.; surlatable.com

THE BIG CHEESE

Dorset Drum English Farmhouse Cheddar, $14.99; iGourmet.com

CANDY CRAVING

Market Pantry Sour Gummi Worms, price varies; Target.com for stores

TOP TOPPING

chocolate strawberry jam, $5.95 for 8-oz. jar; stonewallkitchen.com

PRIMO PASTA

Farro Fusilli Pasta Selezioni Monograno by Valentino Felicetti, $8.50 per 1-lb. package; cybercucina.com

HIT SNACK

Gordy's Pickle Jar Hot Chili Spears, $12 per 16-oz. jar; westelm.com

FAVE DESSERT MIX

Ad Hoc gluten-free brownie mix, $19.95; williams-sonoma.com