Star Tracks: Monday, May 16, 2016 42 years, 2,191 covers and 55,436 stories from PEOPLE magazine's history for you to enjoy
- Katherine Webb Is Working on Getting Back to Her Pre-Baby Body: 'But There's No Rush'
- Read the Cover Story: Brad & Angelina Split After 12 Years: It's Over
- Holiday in the Sun! Mary-Kate Olsen Wears Tiny Black Bikini in the French Riviera
- WATCH: Adriana Lima Demonstrates How to Get Her Signature Sexy Pose
- Rihanna Rocked Central Park, Chris Martin Covered Prince – and the Other Top Moments from Global Citizen Festival
People Top 5
LAST UPDATE: Tuesday February 10, 2015 01:10PM EST
PEOPLE Top 5 are the most-viewed stories on the site over the past three days, updated every 60 minutes
- October 28, 2013
- Vol. 80
- No. 18
22 Years Later: A Murder Mystery Solved
In 1991 a Girl Was Found Battered and Naked in An Ice Cooler. When No Relatives Claimed Her, the Trail Went Cold. But Detectives Refused to Give Up
On Oct. 7 detectives finally learned the identity of their little angel: Anjelica Castillo of Queens. Moving with stunning speed, they tracked down her alleged killer. On Oct. 12 Anjelica's cousin Conrado Juarez, 52, a restaurant kitchen worker, was charged with second-degree murder. At Juarez's arraignment, prosecutor Melissa Mourges, who heads the Manhattan District Attorney's Cold Case Unit, said Juarez had admitted that while sexually forcing himself on Anjelica, he put a pillow over her face, resulting in her suffocation. But Juarez's attorney Michael Croce said Juarez denies the charges and claims the "miraculous confession" had come after a 12- to 14-hour interrogation. With Juarez now in protective custody, detectives have begun delving into Anjelica's family history to find answers to new questions: Had Juarez sexually abused other family members? Why did none of the girl's relatives report her missing?
The identification of Baby Hope combined the methods of modern science with the tenacity of old-fashioned sleuthing. This year, as every year, on the July 23 anniversary of the discovery of Anjelica's remains, detectives revived the case. According to Newsday, the renewed publicity reminded a woman of a conversation she'd had with another woman five years ago in a Laundromat about the Baby Hope case. "That was my sister," the other woman said. In July the woman passed that on to police, which in turn led investigators to one of Anjelica's two sisters; DNA samples that had been exhumed from Anjelica's body matched that on an envelope licked by her mother.
Detectives are just beginning to get a handle on the decades-long silence of Anjelica's family. They now know she was an infant when her parents battled over custody of their three daughters. The oldest landed with their mother, Margarita Castillo. Anjelica and her younger sister remained with their father, Genaro Ramirez, who soon fled to Mexico, leaving them in the care of Balvina Juarez-Ramirez, a cousin who lived with six other relatives in Queens.
In his confession, Juarez, according to police, said that after he killed Anjelica, his sister Juarez-Ramirez directed him to hide Anjelica's body in the cooler. She hailed a black livery cab and helped ditch the cooler in a wooded area. According to The New York Times, relatives were told that "Anjelica is not coming home" and not to ask questions. They complied, many of them reportedly illegal immigrants afraid of police contact. After Juarez-Ramirez's death in the mid-1990s, the youngest daughter was returned to her mother, who was vaguely told years ago about Anjelica. Police are trying to learn why the mother did not contact them at the time. They are also trying to locate Anjelica's father.
"My mother told me Anjelica went missing and she tried really hard to find her," Laurencita Ramirez, 27, told the New York Post. The married Brooklyn mother said she found out about her younger sister's death as a child, when her other sister told her they had a sibling who had been murdered. But it wasn't until Oct. 8 that she learned about the Baby Hope case while watching television. The next day police were knocking on her door.
For Detective Giorgio, at least, there's a sense, at last, of completion. "I'm feeling terrific," he says. That doesn't mean his relationship with Baby Hope has ended. For 22 years, he says, "we referred to her as our baby; she was part of the family." Now newly retired, with two children and two grandchildren of his own, Giorgio still intends to visit Anjelica's grave every year. "I don't have to look for the anniversary anymore," he says, smiling. "I can go anytime."
September 24, 2016
Treat Yourself! 4 Preview Issues
The most buzzed about stars this minute!