Picks and Pans Review: Taylor Swift

updated 11/20/2006 AT 01:00 AM EST

originally published 11/20/2006 AT 01:00 AM EST

Taylor Swift

Sixteen-year-old Taylor Swift may be Nashville's answer to Britney Spears. On her self-titled debut, the Wyomissing, Pa., native is lively and engaging if inevitably lacking in polish and depth. On the appealing hit "Tim McGraw," the singer-guitarist—who wrote or cowrote all the songs on her disc—settles for being perky and cute instead of evocative and insightful. Swift comes off as a typical teenage girl on "Teardrops on My Guitar," but displays a more adult perspective on the superior "Picture to Burn."

bgwhite bgwhite   

DOWNLOAD THIS: "Picture to Burn"
For more information on where to find our Download This picks, go to WWW.PEOPLE.COM/DOWNLOADTHIS

From Our Partners