Grieving, Pale and Emaciated, Israel's Menachem Begin Spends His Retirement in Seclusion
updated 11/28/1983 AT 01:00 AM EST
•originally published 11/28/1983 AT 01:00 AM EST
Begin's behavior did not surprise his closest associates. "His heart is broken," says Yona Klimovitsky, 36, who has served as the Israeli leader's secretary for more than a decade and was as close as a daughter to both Begin and his wife. "He misses Aliza more than one can imagine. He is thoroughly alone now."
Only a year ago, Menachem Begin was among the world's most powerful men. Today, at 70, he is a recluse. He has not only resigned from office, he has retreated from life. Since his resignation, he has not ventured outside the official Prime Minister's residence, which he has still not vacated. His children are furnishing a new apartment for him, but the place is not yet ready. (His successor as Prime Minister, Yitzhak Shamir, continues to live in a three-room walk-up apartment.) Unable to shave due to a skin disorder that covers his face with brown blotches, Begin has grown a long, totally white beard. Exhibiting the classic symptoms of clinical depression, he eats little—vegetables, rice, cottage cheese and eggs prepared by his daughter Leah—and sits day and night in robe and slippers, watching television and rereading books. He sees no one but his children and calls no one on the telephone. When old friends and political allies phone, he parries their inquiries with polite but curt replies. "I telephone him on various developments," says Prime Minister Shamir. "He sounds as if he is interested in things, but I haven't seen him in quite a few weeks."
Begin's nearly catatonic retirement comes after a lifetime of almost constant action. Born in an area of Poland that is now part of Russia, he lost both parents in the Nazi Holocaust and was himself imprisoned in a Soviet labor camp in Siberia. After emigrating to Palestine in 1942, he led the Irgun, the infamous anti-British terrorist group that bombed Jerusalem's King David Hotel in 1946, killing 76 people. For nearly 30 years after Israel achieved independence in 1948, Begin led the right-wing opposition forces in the Knesset while raising his three children in an austere, two-room Tel Aviv apartment. Then, in an upset victory that shocked Israel, he was elected Prime Minister in 1977. The high point of his six-year term was the Nobel prizewinning 1978 peace treaty negotiated by President Jimmy Carter and signed by Begin with Egyptian President Anwar Sadat. The low point was last year's bitter invasion of Lebanon and the subsequent shocking massacres at the Sabra and Shatila refugee camps in Beirut.
It was the war in Lebanon that triggered Begin's emotional decline, says Klimovitsky. "He thought the army would go in, make a quick blitzkrieg and victoriously get out," she says. "Instead, it went on and on, and more and more casualties fell. He feels betrayed by those who led him up the garden path about Lebanon. What disturbs him are the casualties—ours and the Lebanese. That was what made him turn more and more into himself."
Shortly after the Palestinian refugee-camp massacres left Begin reeling, the death of his wife in November 1982 from chronic asthma and a heart attack devastated him. On a state visit to Washington when he heard the news, Begin canceled his appointments with President Reagan and flew home immediately, distraught that he was not with Aliza when she died. "She was his closest associate; they shared everything," says Klimovitsky. "He couldn't go it alone." He lost weight rapidly, and his suits hung over his shrinking frame like cast-off clothing on a coat hanger. His health was failing—he had suffered a massive heart attack in 1977, a stroke in 1979 and another mild heart attack in 1980—and the medicines he took left him groggy. "One spoke to him," said a diplomat, "and he gazed vacantly into space." As the ordeal continued, Begin told a senior aide, "I am no longer master of my body, my body is master of me."
By then, Begin was no longer master of his government either. Throughout the spring and summer of 1983, Israel was rocked with internal troubles—a projected inflation rate of 160 percent and strikes by airline workers and doctors—as well as by continued skirmishing in Lebanon. Begin, once a firm, autocratic administrator and adept parliamentarian, sat silently as his cabinet meetings degenerated into shouting matches. "This government," said Welfare Minister Aharon Uzan in a TV interview in August, "is like a ship without a captain." Two days later a haggard Begin stood up at the end of a cabinet meeting and almost inaudibly announced his resignation. "Please, let me be," he said. "I cannot continue any longer."
For days crowds demonstrated outside the Prime Minister's residence. "Begin, Begin, do not leave us," they screamed. During that period, Begin received aides who urged him to reconsider. He turned down their pleas, and in early September he locked the gates and allowed no more visitors. Even Klimovitsky was barred. She, however, remains understanding. "Look, he is going through a period of deep sadness," she says. "Every person needs a quiet corner to relax in." Klimovitsky refuses to give up on Begin. "When he feels better, he will write the books he wants to—a biography of Garibaldi and three volumes entitled From Holocaust to Redemption." When Begin is ready to write, Klimovitsky will be there to help him.