09/18/1995 at 01:00 AM EDT
Dumbstruck by her figure instead of her fashions, our judges could only invoke a higher power for the Baywatch beauty, formerly Anderson, who changed her surname when she wed rocker Tommy Lee in February. Dave's World's Matthews: "Oh, my God!" Melrose Place costumer Wingate: "God!" RuPaul: "God!" Matthews recovered to observe of the 28-year-old actress who was once Home Improvement's Tool Time Girl: "If you put her entire wardrobe together, it would make just one outfit I would wear."