As Brooke Shields
's wisecracking best friend Vicki Groener on NBC's Suddenly Susan
, the 32-year-old comedian is relegated to wearing side-kick clothes like "crazy-Rhoda paisley pants," as she laments in her stand-up routine. But she fares no better in real life, dressing too goofy for her own good, according to our judges. "She seems to favor her midriff, and obviously she's been doing those ab exercises," says designer Marc Bouwer. "But there's no real sense of personal style." And although the 5'4" native Chicagoan knows her colors ("I'm an autumn," she informed viewers of last month's HBO special Kathy Griffin: Hot Cup of Talk
), when it comes to the rest of the outfit, she tries too hard. "She has beautiful hair and a nice face too," says Fashion Emergency
's Emme. "She doesn't have to be so wild in order to be noticed. Sorry, Kathy."