Danny Bonaduce is being investigated for battery for tossing ex-Survivor contestant Jonny Fairplay over his shoulder during an award show Tuesday.
Fairplay, 33, filed a police report Wednesday claiming that his teeth were knocked out during the incident at the FOX Reality Really Channel awards held at the Hollywood club Boulevard3, the Associated Press reports.
Police received the battery report around 2 a.m. at a Hollywood hospital where Fairplay was being treated, Officer April Harding told the AP.
"He had one tooth broken, another tooth missing from his gum line and two other teeth that were loose," she said.
During the awards show, Fairplay was being jeered onstage when Bonaduce, 48, came onto the stage and said into the microphone, "They're booing because they hate you." (Fairplay, a wrestler who came in third on the 2003's Survivor: Pearl Islands, was criticized by many viewers for having lied about the death of lie his grandmother in order to win sympathy from other competitors.)
According to police, Fairplay said he then tried to hug Bonaduce. In a video clip of the incident, Fairplay is seen jumping into Bonaduce's arms. In reaction, Bonaduce tossed Fairplay up and over his head and onto the floor. Fairplay then got up and ran offstage while holding his hand over his mouth.
Kevin Winter / Getty
Fairplay told the site that he underwent 2 1⁄2 hours of dental surgery and still needs additional work.
"It knocked one tooth out and then it moved three others," he said. "One tooth is, like, shattered eight times."
Who's turning 40? Which celebs are high school dropouts? What's hot and definitely not in fall fashion? Check out PEOPLE's new digital magazine now!