Who would win a battle of the brothers bands: the Naked Brothers Band or the Jonas Brothers? The answer is clear from the former's second album: The Jonases don't have anything to worry about just yet. Still, the brothers Wolff—Nat, 13, and Alex, 10—easily score passable marks for School, which features songs from the second season of their hit Nickelodeon show The Naked Brothers Band. They certainly get bonus points for writing all their own material, with Nat composing and singing lead on 10 of 12 tunes, including the title-track highlight, a bluesy rocker. But while Nat's choirboy croon on the ballad "I'll Do Anything" will make you melt, Alex's pitchy attempt to convey heartbreak on "Why" will make you ask just that.
For more information on where to find our Download This picks, go to PEOPLE.COM/DOWNLOADTHIS