First, it was dinner at the Waverly Inn, where the couple was joined by three other people in a quiet dinner near the back garden. Mayer's animated stories kept Aniston laughing as the group sipped white wine and ate a leisurely dinner. At one point, Aniston rubbed Mayer's neck as the couple spoke quietly to each other.
After dinner, it was on to Hudson Bar and Books, where the group stayed for more than an hour, sipping champagne. Mayer and Aniston weren’t shy about showing their affection for each other – kissing, hugging and posing for photos together. When music started playing, Mayer did a lighthearted – and goofy – little dance.
It was the third city where Mayer and Aniston have spent some quality time together. After getting cozy poolside in Miami on Saturday, they flew to Orlando, where they were spotted kissing backstage at his concert.
Reporting by AMANDA FRIEDMAN, STEPHANIE RYGORSKY & KRISTEN MASCIA