Simon Cowell and Sting Trade Barbs

Simon Cowell and Sting Trade Barbs
Simon Cowell and Sting
Flynet; Donna Ward/Meet the Famous

11/16/2009 AT 11:35 AM EST

He's usually the one meting out the criticism, but this time it's Simon Cowell who's on the receiving end of some particularly harsh words about his talent – from Sting.

The rock star heaped criticism on Cowell's British version of American IdolThe X Factor – describing the show as "appalling" and promoting bland, soulless music in an interview with the London Evening Standard.

"It's a preposterous show, and you have judges who have no recognizable talent apart from self-promotion," Sting, 58, said. "Basically I was looking at televised karaoke where they conform to stereotypes. It is a soap opera which has nothing to do with music."

One of those judges, of course, is Cowell, 50, who offered a riposte to Sting's stings on Saturday's live X Factor show.

"Talking about these contestants being a bunch of karaoke no-hopers … I thought it was pompous," he said, before inviting Sting to come on the show as a mentor.

On Sunday, Cowell followed up again on The Xtra Factor. "Someone has got a little bit grumpy," he joked with his co-judges. "We'd like a Sting week."

But he later admitted: "He hasn't called yet. We're waiting!

Don't hold your breath, Simon. In his interview, Sting made it clear he had no interest in setting foot on the X Factor stage.

"I wouldn't get on The X Factor because I don't sound like anyone they're after," he said. "I sound like myself. I think they are basically aping pre-existing stereotypes of what singers should do and they're not being themselves."

See what other readers have to say about this story – or leave a comment of your own
MORE ON: Simon Cowell

From Our Partners