Taylor Swift and Taylor Lautner Get Friendly Over Fro-Yo

Friday December 04, 2009 03:30 PM EST

Taylor Swift and Taylor Lautner

GSI Media

A little Fro-Yo for Taylors-squared as the teens – Swift and Lautner, of course – enjoyed dinner at Benihana and dessert at frozen yogurt shop Menchie's on Thursday after re-shooting some Valentine's Day scenes

"[Swift] opted for a huge frozen yogurt and [Lautner] watched her eat it with a huge smile," says an observer, noting they attracted attention from customers and gladly posed for fan pictures. "They both seemed very down to earth and friendly."

Swift, 19, just earned eight Grammy nominations and was last spotted with Twilight hunk Lautner, 17, in October.

– Pernilla Cedenheim