The Bounty Hunter duo continued their love fest Tuesday night at their film's New York City premiere at the Ziegfeld Theater, where Aniston told PEOPLE of her downtime in the kitchen, "I love to cook."
Butler shared his passion for Aniston's cooking as well. "Mexican," he stressed. "She has a big thing with Mexico and Mexican food. And I had a great night of Mexican food and a whole bunch of people ... over at her house, she had a big to-do, and she had a lot of friends over and it was delicious."
And what meal is complete without dessert? Butler is equally sweet on Aniston's baking skills. "She makes a good cupcake," he said. "And I'm good at eating them."