For those reasons and more, McGraw is hands down PEOPLE Country's hottest guy – but, he jokes, he might not rank in the Top Two as far as his wife, Faith Hill, is concerned.
"My wife would pick George Strait," he says. "She thinks he's gorgeous! Or Kris Kristofferson. When we're around him, she can barely speak."
With a new no-alcohol policy and a tough workout routine, McGraw has managed to lose 37 lbs. and, he says, feels better than ever. "I don't feel whatever 43 is supposed to feel like – I still feel pretty young," he says. "I'm more confident than I've ever been about who I am and what I do and I feel like I've got a lot more ahead of me than I do behind me."
Joining McGraw on PEOPLE Country's hot guy list: Kenny Chesney, Keith Urban, Brad Paisley, Blake Shelton and a host of other sexy men, including – note to Hill – George Strait.
For the full interview with McGraw and photos of all 25 hot country guys, pick up the new issue of PEOPLE Country, on newsstands beginning June 18