Ali Fedotowsky Has Her Wedding Playlist – and First Dance – All Planned
"I want it to be simple: one person, one instrument and that's it," Fedotowsky tells PEOPLE. "I think absolutely a violinist for that. My favorite music is like Jack Johnson, Schuyler Fisk . . . who sit down with a guitar and sing. That's what I want at our wedding – that rawness."
But when it comes time for the reception, guests had better be ready to dance.
"Our wedding will be a lot of dancing and celebrating," she says. "A live band, and absolutely salsa dancing. Every kind of dancing! I'm actually envisioning Roberto and I making up a dance – a funny, quirky dance that are going to laugh at."
When asked if they've chosen a first-dance song yet, Fedotowsky hints that "Bendita tu luz," a song Martinez introduced to her, may be the one. "It's beautiful," she says, recalling the moment she first heard the Maná tune. "It was our first weekend together in our hideaway house and he put it on, and we laid in bed and we were holding each other, and he said, 'This song makes me think of you.' It's our own organic song."
However, if it were up to Martinez, they might be hitting the dance floor to a slightly different melody. "Roberto loves the Lion King song," she shares. "It's so cute."
The reality star is expanding her musical horizons these days. In fact, she even bought a pink guitar after falling for Schuyler Fisk's single, "From Where I'm Standing." "It was on my Bachelor audition video," she says. "I loved the song so much, I was determined to learn to play it on the guitar." – Kate Hogan and Charlotte Triggs
For more on Ali's wedding planning – including details about her dress and cake! – pick up this week's PEOPLE, on newsstands now