12/17/2009 at 12:00 AM EST
Gleeks have been geeking out over the possibility of Broadway star Idina Menzel
sweeping her way onto the hit FOX show Glee
, but don't get your broomsticks out just yet.
"I don't know what I'm doing with Idina yet," show creator Ryan Murphy
told PEOPLE at a Hollywood Radio and Television Society panel on Wednesday. "I just met with her once. It sort of got leaked, but I haven’t plotted it out yet."
Menzel, who originated the role of Elphaba, the Wicked Witch of the West in the hit Broadway musical Wicked
, and Lea Michele
, the actress who plays Rachel Berry on Glee
and sang Wicked
's signature number "Defying Gravity," look a lot alike, a fact not lost on Menzel nor her husband, Private Practice
star Taye Diggs
, who recently said, "We knew that resemblance existed far, far before the TV world did." That resemblance has some hoping the Tony-winner will play the biological mother of Rachel, who is the proud daughter of two gay dads.
While fans will have to wait to see what, if anything, Murphy comes up with, Glee
will ease on down the road for Kristin Chenoweth
, who played Glinda the Good Witch in Wicked
. Chenoweth will return as former McKinley High glee club star April Rhodes
in the spring.
"I know Kristin has a huge episode," Murphy said. "She's coming back because we write that for her, but there are some other coming that I can't say, but they are big music , so I’m very excited!" --Cynthia WangTell us: How should Idina Menzel be cast in Glee?