SPOILER ALERT: Find Out Bachelor Jason’s Pick
03/03/2009 AT 12:00 AM EST
It was down to Melissa and Molly, the last two women standing on the Bachelor finale. Continue reading to see which woman Jason Mesnick chose.
In a stunning conclusion to this season’s Bachelor, Jason gave an engagement ring to Melissa ... but gave his heart to Molly.
While Jason Mesnick proposed to Melissa Rycroft in the show's finale, just six weeks later he changed his mind and decided instead to pursue a relationship with the show’s other finalist, Molly Malaney.
After spending much of Monday night's two-hour finale debating whether he would propose to Molly or Melissa, Jason popped the question to an elated Melissa, who quickly accepted. But the couple's seemingly happy ending was short-lived.
On The Bachelor: After the Final Rose, which immediately followed the finale Monday night but had been taped six weeks after the earlier program, Jason stunningly revealed to host Chris Harrison that things were not going to work out with Melissa, in large part because he still had strong feelings for Molly.
"Over the last few weeks, I haven't been able to stop thinking about Molly," Jason said. "If I could change the way I feel... I would do that, but I can't."
Next, he revealed his feelings to Melissa, who angrily stormed off the set. A wary Molly appeared and allowed Jason to plead his case for a second chance. Ultimately, she agreed to give their love another shot.
What does Jason think of his actions, and what's next for him and Molly? Check back Tuesday on PEOPLE.com for an exclusive interview with him!