That's what American Idol producers are hoping come season 10.
On Wednesday, Ryan Seacrest announced that the Aerosmith singer and Lopez will be joining Randy Jackson on the judging panel as the audition process is set to begin.
Also out this year: Ellen DeGeneres and Kara DioGuardi.
Who will be the brutally honest judge? And who will hold contestants' hands through the process? It's too early to tell – but tell us: