The two were married Sunday in Ojai, just north of L.A., in an outdoor ceremony, PEOPLE confirms.
Yustman wore 10 carats of diamond earrings and 30-carat diamond and platinum barrettes from Neil Lane. Her gown was by Monique Lhuillier, while Annable was dressed in DKNY.
Making the decision to propose to Yustman earlier this year in Santa Barbara was easy for Annable. "I knew," he told PEOPLE at the time. "And when you know, you know."
The couple, who dated for a year-and-a-half before their engagement, are looking forward to becoming parents – sooner rather than later.
"I want a little hockey team," Annable says. "I'm a little bit older than she is ... I'm going grey, I wear cardigans now. It's time, you know, I have the itch."