Clockwise, from top left: Jon Hamm, James Franco, Tom Welling, Sam Worthington
CelebrityPhoto, Landov, Startraks, Getty
10/14/2010 AT 07:00 AM EDT
Now that 300
filmmaker Zack Snyder has been announced as director for the upcoming big-screen Superman
reboot, buzz is building about who will wear the Man of Steel's famous red cape.
PEOPLE polled the experts – superfans at last week's New York Comic Con – for their picks, with the top four favorites listed below.