From left: Steven Tyler, Jennifer Lopez and Randy Jackson
03/09/2011 AT 07:15 PM EST
's season 10 top 13 contestants took the stage on Wednesday – but were they all Idol
-worthy? Relive the night's biggest hits (and misses!) and take a look back at the performances, the outfits, the judges' commentary – and see what you
had to say, all in our live blog recap!