Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux Step Out in N.Y.C. – in Similar Rings

By Rennie Dyball

06/16/2011 at 03:00 PM EDT

They may not be smooching in public, but it looks like Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux may be displaying another (more subtle) PDA.

The couple was spotted leaving the Gramercy Park Hotel in New York Wednesday, wearing similar gold rings on their left ring fingers.

But this is not the first time that Aniston, 42, and Theroux, 39 – who have been quietly dating since May – donned the chunky gold bands.

RELATED: Jennifer Aniston Parties with New Man Justin Theroux

Theroux has been photographed wearing a gold ring on that finger at an event in April, while the actress (whose ring says "Jennifer") has been spotted in hers several times this month.

Earlier in June, the couple spent a weekend together in Los Angeles, dining in West Hollywood and attending a Soho House bash after the MTV Movie Awards.