Minka Kelly and Derek Jeter
Wenzelberg/Splash News Online; Reuters/Landov
07/14/2011 AT 06:00 AM EDT
quietly celebrated his 3,000th hit
with girlfriend Minka Kelly
, friends and family inside Southern Hospitality in N.Y.C. The group gathered downstairs, where guests toasted the Yankees captain with Armand de Brignac champagne and mini-cupcakes in a private room adorned with Yankee baseball balloons, as well as a silver balloon sculpture that spelled out "3,000 Hits."