Caught in the Act

Emily & John's Near Double-Date with Ryan Phillippe & Amanda Seyfried

04/25/2011 at 03:00 PM EDT

Emily Blunt and John Krasinski stopped in for dinner at Fig & Olive Melrose Place in L.A. – and the two were in "high spirits," a source says. They ordered the newly-opened restaurant's signature dishes, like rosemary lamb chops, and jovially chatted up the general manager. The same night, Ryan Phillippe and Amanda Seyfried shared a PDA and laughter-filled dinner at the eatery.