Caught in the Act

Emma Stone & Andrew Garfield Have a Date with Elmo

11/07/2011 at 11:55 AM EST

The Amazing Spider-Man costars – and rumored real-life couple – Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield sure seemed cozy during an early evening movie and coffee outing in L.A. The duo stopped by L.A.'s Laemmle Sunset 5 Theater, where they caught the documentary Being Elmo: A Puppeteer's Journey. The two were also spotted at a Starbucks, just downstairs from the theater. Stone ordered a regular coffee, and the two cuddled a bit while they waited in line, an onlooker tells us, noting that Garfield had his hands partially around Stone's waist. Says the onlooker: "They were really cute." – Marisa Laudadio and Jessica Wedemeyer

NEXT: Ryan Seacrest, Julianne Hough Dine à Deux in West Hollywood >