11/21/2011 AT 05:30 PM EST
"My house is packed with puppets. Like, everywhere. Thank God I have a slightly bigger house now, so I have one room that's sort of dedicated to puppets. But for a long time I lived in a one-bedroom apartment that was just crammed with puppets. It's why I'm still single."
writer and star Jason Segel, 31, jokes with New York
about looking for a lady