12/14/2011 AT 05:55 AM EST
, who recently competed on Dancing with the Stars
, scoped out the goods and loaded up on stocking stuffers at Real Simple
's Holiday Pop-Up Shop in New York. The stylist joked with the crowd, "I love anything that pops up!" Also spotted browsing: Dylan Lauren
, who owns Dylan's Candy Bar, and Top Chef
's Gail Simmons
, who gave a demonstration of her famous peanut butter and jelly French toast recipe for shoppers.