12/23/2011 AT 06:00 AM EST
Looks like they're having a sweet holiday season! Emma Stone
and beau Andrew Garfield got affectionate
with each other while shopping at Eleni's in New York's Chelsea Market. The Amazing Spider-Man stars
purchased the Chilly Chocolate Chip tin – which includes chocolate chip cookies as well as sugar cookies cut into snowflakes and snowmen. And an onlooker tells us, "She was rubbing his back while ordering." The new couple, who entered the store holding hands, kept up the "cute couply stuff" during their visit.