Alex Rodriguez and Torrie Wilson
Janet Mayer/Splash News Online; Paul Drinkwater/NBC
12/30/2011 AT 02:15 PM EST
Leave it to wrestlers to pin down the world's most eligible bachelors.
After former WWE beauty Stacy Keibler got a grasp
on George Clooney
, her pal Torrie Wilson, a former wrestling diva and a 2004 Playboy
cover model, has been spending time with New York Yankees star Alex Rodriguez.
Before Christmas, all four joined other friends on a getaway to Cabo San Lucas, and Rodriguez and Wilson, both 36, on another occasion reportedly were seen riding bicycles in Miami.
Then on Monday, Rodriquez and Wilson were working out in the same gym in her hometown of Boise, Idaho, says local TV anchor Mike Murad, who was also in the gym and Tweeted a photo
of Rodriguez on an exercise bike.
"I did speak with him briefly," Murad tells the Idaho Statesman.
"He didn't tell me why he was here, but did tell me he was trying to keep a low profile."