02/24/2012 at 05:55 AM EST
was beefing up on the protein during a visit to The Counter in Century City, Calif. The football star ordered a turkey burger with a fried egg on top, and was extremely nice to the staff. He didn't go unnoticed by his fellow diners, either. According to a source, Tebow
snapped pictures with customers and chatted up his fans.
The athlete hasn't been shirking his exercise during the off-season, either. He's also been recently spotted at Equinox in L.A., where he's been working on the strength floor and, during a separate visit, hitting up the spa. – Jennifer Garcia and Charlotte Triggs